Is Trading Aaron Judge a Smart Move? Exploring Potential MLB Trade Scenarios

Discover whether trading Aaron Judge in fantasy baseball is a viable strategy, with detailed trade scenarios and player evaluations.

Aaron Judge's Dominance in 2025

Aaron Judge has been a powerhouse in the 2025 MLB season, leading in multiple statistical categories. With a batting average of .387, an OPS of 1.242, and 21 home runs, Judge is a top performer in fantasy baseball. His Wins Above Replacement (WAR) of 4.7 further cements his status as a key player for the New York Yankees.

The Case for Trading Judge

Despite Judge's stellar performance, some fantasy managers might consider trading him to address other roster needs. Here are some potential trade scenarios:

Trade Judge for Shohei Ohtani

Shohei Ohtani is making strides towards returning to the mound. While Judge leads in fantasy points, Ohtani's dual-threat capability could provide a significant boost, especially if he pitches regularly.

Trade Judge for Tarik Skubal and Jackson Chourio

If your team needs pitching, Tarik Skubal could be a valuable addition. Pairing him with a promising hitter like Jackson Chourio could balance your roster effectively.

Trade Judge for Bobby Witt Jr. and Cristopher Sanchez

Bobby Witt Jr. is a reliable shortstop with potential for growth. Adding a pitcher like Cristopher Sanchez could make this trade appealing for teams looking to strengthen multiple positions.

Trade Judge for Garrett Crochet and Corbin Carroll

This trade could benefit teams lacking depth. Garrett Crochet and Corbin Carroll are promising young players who could provide long-term value.

Trade Judge for Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Joe Ryan

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has underperformed but has a history of strong seasons. Pairing him with a solid pitcher like Joe Ryan could be a strategic move.

Trade Judge for Jackson Merrill, Ketel Marte, and Shea Langeliers

This trade could help teams with hitting depth issues. Jackson Merrill and Ketel Marte are consistent performers, and Shea Langeliers could add power to your lineup.

Conclusion

Trading Aaron Judge is a complex decision that depends on your team's specific needs. While Judge is a top-tier player, exploring trade options could help balance your roster and improve overall performance.

What to Read Next

Ultimate Guide to MLB Fantasy Baseball Lineups and Betting Tips for Friday
MLB

Ultimate Guide to MLB Fantasy Baseball Lineups and Betting Tips for Friday

Get expert MLB fantasy baseball lineup advice and betting tips for Friday's games, including starting pitcher rankings and key matchups.

Nolan McLean Makes History: First Mets Pitcher to Win First Four MLB Starts
MLB

Nolan McLean Makes History: First Mets Pitcher to Win First Four MLB Starts

Rookie Nolan McLean leads the Mets to victory, becoming the first pitcher in team history to win his first four MLB starts.

MLB 2025 Season Power Rankings: September Stretch Run Highlights Top Teams and Playoff Contenders
MLB

MLB 2025 Season Power Rankings: September Stretch Run Highlights Top Teams and Playoff Contenders

As the 2025 MLB season enters its final stretch, discover the top teams making their push for the playoffs and the key players driving their success.

MLB Free Agency 2026: Key Players, Big Contracts, and Emerging Stars
MLB

MLB Free Agency 2026: Key Players, Big Contracts, and Emerging Stars

Explore the 2026 MLB free agency landscape, featuring top players like Kyle Tucker and Kyle Schwarber, and emerging stars from Japan such as Tatsuya Imai and Munetaka Murakami.

Cubs' Cade Horton Shines with No-Hit Performance Despite Early Hook
MLB

Cubs' Cade Horton Shines with No-Hit Performance Despite Early Hook

Cubs rookie Cade Horton delivers a stunning no-hit performance for five innings, showcasing his potential as a top MLB rookie despite an early hook by manager Craig Counsell.

Christian Yelich Sidelined with Back Injury as Brewers Face Phillies in Crucial Series
MLB

Christian Yelich Sidelined with Back Injury as Brewers Face Phillies in Crucial Series

Christian Yelich scratched from Brewers' lineup due to back soreness as Milwaukee faces Philadelphia in a pivotal NL series.

Isaac Paredes' Hamstring Recovery: Will the Astros' Third Baseman Return This Season?
MLB

Isaac Paredes' Hamstring Recovery: Will the Astros' Third Baseman Return This Season?

Astros' third baseman Isaac Paredes tests his hamstring with running and fielding, but his return this season remains uncertain.

Detroit Tigers' Kyle Finnegan Sidelined with Groin Injury in Crucial Win Over Mets
MLB

Detroit Tigers' Kyle Finnegan Sidelined with Groin Injury in Crucial Win Over Mets

Detroit Tigers' closer Kyle Finnegan suffered a groin injury during warm-up, missing the game against the Mets, but the team secured a 6-2 victory.

MLB Trade Deadline Impact: Analyzing Team Performance One Month Later
MLB

MLB Trade Deadline Impact: Analyzing Team Performance One Month Later

A comprehensive analysis of how MLB teams have fared one month after the trade deadline, highlighting key performances and playoff prospects.

Ha-Seong Kim Shines in Braves Debut Despite Loss to Cubs
MLB

Ha-Seong Kim Shines in Braves Debut Despite Loss to Cubs

Ha-Seong Kim makes an impressive debut with the Atlanta Braves, going 2-for-4 in a narrow loss to the Chicago Cubs.

MLB Playoff Push: Rising Stars Jonah Tong and Payton Tolle Lead Key Pickups
MLB

MLB Playoff Push: Rising Stars Jonah Tong and Payton Tolle Lead Key Pickups

Discover the top MLB rookies and key pickups for the fantasy baseball playoffs, including Jonah Tong and Payton Tolle, who are making waves in their debuts.

MLB September Showdown: Expert Predictions on Playoff Contenders and Division Races
MLB

MLB September Showdown: Expert Predictions on Playoff Contenders and Division Races

As the MLB season heads into its final month, experts weigh in on which teams will dominate September, secure playoff spots, and win tight division races.

September Showdown: Ranking the Most Exciting MLB Playoff Races to Watch
MLB

September Showdown: Ranking the Most Exciting MLB Playoff Races to Watch

As September begins, we rank the most thrilling MLB playoff races, from wild card battles to division title chases, that will define the final month of the season.

2025 MLB Playoff Tracker: Key Matchups, Clinching Scenarios, and Postseason Schedule
MLB

2025 MLB Playoff Tracker: Key Matchups, Clinching Scenarios, and Postseason Schedule

Stay updated with the latest on the 2025 MLB playoffs, including key matchups, clinching scenarios, and the full postseason schedule.

Ultimate MLB Fantasy Baseball and Betting Guide for Tuesday: Expert Tips and Lineup Strategies
MLB

Ultimate MLB Fantasy Baseball and Betting Guide for Tuesday: Expert Tips and Lineup Strategies

Get expert MLB fantasy baseball lineup advice and betting tips for Tuesday's games. Learn about top pitchers, hitters, and betting strategies to maximize your fantasy and betting success.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.