NFL Offseason Grades 2025: Top Moves, Surprises, and Missteps Across the League

The 2025 NFL offseason has been a whirlwind of activity, with teams making bold moves to position themselves for success. From the Los Angeles Rams' savvy retention of Matthew Stafford to the New Orleans Saints' questionable decisions, here's a detailed look at how each team fared.

Los Angeles Rams: A

Biggest Move: Retaining QB Matthew Stafford Move I Liked: Receiving a future first-round pick in a draft-day trade with Atlanta Move I Disliked: Re-signing WR Tutu Atwell

The Rams had a stellar offseason, making moves that benefit both the present and future. Retaining Stafford was crucial, and the draft-day trade with Atlanta added valuable assets. However, re-signing Atwell raised eyebrows.

San Francisco 49ers: A-

Biggest Move: Signing QB Brock Purdy to an extension Move I Liked: Hiring Robert Saleh as defensive coordinator Move I Disliked: None

The 49ers made smart moves, extending Purdy and bringing back Saleh. Their offseason was solid, with no major missteps.

Arizona Cardinals: A-

Biggest Move: Signing Edge Josh Sweat Move I Liked: Extending TE Trey McBride Move I Disliked: Not re-signing G Will Hernandez

The Cardinals addressed key needs, signing Sweat and extending McBride. However, failing to re-sign Hernandez was a missed opportunity.

Denver Broncos: A-

Biggest Move: Re-signing DT D.J. Jones Move I Liked: Re-signing Jones Move I Disliked: Not adding more at wide receiver

The Broncos focused on defense, re-signing Jones and adding talent. However, they could have done more to bolster their receiving corps.

Baltimore Ravens: B+

Biggest Move: Re-signing LT Ronnie Stanley Move I Liked: Signing CB Chidobe Awuzie Move I Disliked: Drafting Edge Mike Green in the second round

The Ravens made solid moves, re-signing Stanley and adding Awuzie. However, drafting Green was a questionable decision.

Tennessee Titans: B+

Biggest Move: Drafting QB Cameron Ward Move I Liked: Signing G Kevin Zeitler Move I Disliked: Signing Edge Dre'Mont Jones

The Titans made key moves, drafting Ward and signing Zeitler. However, signing Jones was a questionable move.

Buffalo Bills: B+

Biggest Move: Extending QB Josh Allen Move I Liked: Extending WR Khalil Shakir Move I Disliked: Signing WR Joshua Palmer

The Bills focused on extending key players, including Allen and Shakir. However, signing Palmer was a questionable move.

Philadelphia Eagles: B+

Biggest Move: Re-signing LB Zack Baun Move I Liked: Re-signing Baun Move I Disliked: Trading S C.J. Gardner-Johnson for G Kenyon Green and light draft capital

The Eagles made solid moves, re-signing Baun. However, trading Gardner-Johnson was a questionable decision.

Cleveland Browns: B+

Biggest Move: Trading down from No. 2 to No. 5 in the draft Move I Liked: Trading down in the draft Move I Disliked: Signing Edge Myles Garrett to an extension

The Browns made smart moves, trading down in the draft. However, extending Garrett was a questionable decision.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: B+

Biggest Move: Re-signing WR Chris Godwin Move I Liked: Signing Edge Haason Reddick Move I Disliked: None

The Buccaneers made solid moves, re-signing Godwin and adding Reddick. Their offseason was solid, with no major missteps.

Houston Texans: B+

Biggest Move: Trading away OT Laremy Tunsil Move I Liked: Trading down from No. 25 to No. 34 in the draft Move I Disliked: Trading for G Ed Ingram

The Texans made bold moves, trading Tunsil and trading down in the draft. However, trading for Ingram was a questionable decision.

New York Jets: B

Biggest Move: Hiring head coach Aaron Glenn Move I Liked: Signing QB Justin Fields Move I Disliked: Not extending WR Garrett Wilson and CB Sauce Gardner

The Jets made smart moves, hiring Glenn and signing Fields. However, failing to extend Wilson and Gardner was a missed opportunity.

Las Vegas Raiders: B

Biggest Move: Trading for QB Geno Smith Move I Liked: Re-signing DT Adam Butler Move I Disliked: Drafting RB Ashton Jeanty at No. 6

The Raiders made bold moves, trading for Smith and re-signing Butler. However, drafting Jeanty was a questionable decision.

Indianapolis Colts: B

Biggest Move: Signing QB Daniel Jones to a one-year, $14 million deal Move I Liked: Signing CB Charvarius Ward Move I Disliked: None

The Colts made smart moves, signing Jones and adding Ward. Their offseason was solid, with no major missteps.

New York Giants: B

Biggest Move: Trading up for QB Jaxson Dart Move I Liked: Signing QB Jameis Winston Move I Disliked: Signing CB Paulson Adebo

The Giants made bold moves, trading up for Dart and signing Winston. However, signing Adebo was a questionable decision.

Los Angeles Chargers: B

Biggest Move: Drafting RB Omarion Hampton in the first round Move I Liked: Signing G Mekhi Becton Move I Disliked: Not adding more at edge rusher

The Chargers made key moves, drafting Hampton and signing Becton. However, they could have done more to bolster their pass rush.

Chicago Bears: B-

Biggest Move: Hiring Ben Johnson Move I Liked: Hiring Johnson Move I Disliked: Signing DT Grady Jarrett to a deal that includes significant 2026 guarantees

The Bears made smart moves, hiring Johnson. However, signing Jarrett was a questionable decision.

Detroit Lions: B-

Biggest Move: Extending S Kerby Joseph Move I Liked: Signing CB D.J. Reed Move I Disliked: Reaching for DT Tyleik Williams and WR Isaac TeSlaa

The Lions made solid moves, extending Joseph and adding Reed. However, reaching for Williams and TeSlaa was a questionable decision.

Seattle Seahawks: B-

Biggest Move: Trading QB Geno Smith Move I Liked: Guaranteeing only $37.5 million to QB Sam Darnold Move I Disliked: Not signing a free agent guard

The Seahawks made bold moves, trading Smith and signing Darnold. However, failing to sign a guard was a missed opportunity.

Miami Dolphins: B-

Biggest Move: Trading CB Jalen Ramsey and TE Jonnu Smith for S Minkah Fitzpatrick Move I Liked: Trading Ramsey and Smith for Fitzpatrick Move I Disliked: Signing QB Zach Wilson

The Dolphins made smart moves, trading Ramsey and Smith for Fitzpatrick. However, signing Wilson was a questionable decision.

Kansas City Chiefs: B-

Biggest Move: Trading G Joe Thuney to the Bears for a fourth-round pick Move I Liked: Signing QB Gardner Minshew Move I Disliked: Signing OT Jaylon Moore

The Chiefs made bold moves, trading Thuney and signing Minshew. However, signing Moore was a questionable decision.

Green Bay Packers: C+

Biggest Move: Signing G Aaron Banks Move I Liked: Drafting WR Matthew Golden at No. 23 Move I Disliked: Signing Banks

The Packers made key moves, drafting Golden. However, signing Banks was a questionable decision.

New England Patriots: C+

Biggest Move: Hiring head coach Mike Vrabel Move I Liked: Hiring Vrabel Move I Disliked: Signing DT Milton Williams

The Patriots made smart moves, hiring Vrabel. However, signing Williams was a questionable decision.

Minnesota Vikings: C+

Biggest Move: Sticking with QB J.J. McCarthy as their starter Move I Liked: Sticking with McCarthy Move I Disliked: Signing DT Jonathan Allen

The Vikings made smart moves, sticking with McCarthy. However, signing Allen was a questionable decision.

Cincinnati Bengals: C+

Biggest Move: Extending WR Ja'Marr Chase Move I Liked: Extending Chase Move I Disliked: Not working out a new deal with Edge Trey Hendrickson

The Bengals made key moves, extending Chase. However, failing to extend Hendrickson was a missed opportunity.

Washington Commanders: C

Biggest Move: Trading for OT Laremy Tunsil Move I Liked: Releasing DT Jonathan Allen Move I Disliked: Signing DT Javon Kinlaw

The Commanders made bold moves, trading for Tunsil. However, signing Kinlaw was a questionable decision.

Jacksonville Jaguars: C

Biggest Move: Trading up to draft WR/CB Travis Hunter Move I Liked: Signing OL Patrick Mekari Move I Disliked: Signing WR Dyami Brown for one year, $10 million

The Jaguars made bold moves, trading up for Hunter. However, signing Brown was a questionable decision.

Pittsburgh Steelers: C

Biggest Move: Signing QB Aaron Rodgers Move I Liked: Earning four projected compensatory picks Move I Disliked: Trading Minkah Fitzpatrick for Jalen Ramsey and Jonnu Smith

The Steelers made bold moves, signing Rodgers. However, trading Fitzpatrick was a questionable decision.

Carolina Panthers: C

Biggest Move: Signing CB Jaycee Horn to an extension Move I Liked: Signing RB Rico Dowdle Move I Disliked: Signing DT Tershawn Wharton

The Panthers made key moves, extending Horn and signing Dowdle. However, signing Wharton was a questionable decision.

Dallas Cowboys: C

Biggest Move: Trading for WR George Pickens Move I Liked: Drafting Edge Donovan Ezeiruaku in Round 2 Move I Disliked: Letting RB Rico Dowdle walk in exchange for Javonte Williams and Miles Sanders

The Cowboys made bold moves, trading for Pickens. However, letting Dowdle walk was a questionable decision.

Atlanta Falcons: C-

Biggest Move: Trading up to draft Edge James Pearce Jr. Move I Liked: Letting C Drew Dalman walk and making C Ryan Neuzil the starter Move I Disliked: Trading up to select Pearce

The Falcons made bold moves, trading up for Pearce. However, letting Dalman walk was a questionable decision.

New Orleans Saints: D

Biggest Move: Lucking into QB Derek Carr's retirement Move I Liked: Drafting QB Tyler Shough at No. 40 Move I Disliked: Trying to pay Carr before he retired

The Saints made questionable moves, trying to pay Carr before his retirement. However, drafting Shough was a smart move.