Rising Stars and Falling Prospects in the USMNT Gold Cup 2025

The 2025 Gold Cup has been a pivotal tournament for the U.S. Men's National Team (USMNT), offering a platform for emerging talents to shine and for established players to reaffirm their worth. With several key players absent, the spotlight has turned to the next generation of USMNT stars.

Malik Tillman: The Game-Changer

Malik Tillman has been the standout performer for the USMNT in this year's Gold Cup. The 23-year-old PSV Eindhoven midfielder has netted three goals in the group stage, with two additional goals controversially disallowed. His performances have not only solidified his place in the starting lineup but have also attracted attention from Bundesliga giants Bayer Leverkusen. Tillman's ability to influence games with his creativity and work ethic has been a revelation, making him a crucial asset for the upcoming FIFA World Cup.

Johnny Cardoso: A Missed Opportunity

On the flip side, Johnny Cardoso has struggled to make an impact. Despite high expectations, the Real Betis midfielder has seen limited action, featuring for just 11 minutes across two matches. Illness sidelined him for the opener, and his subsequent performances have failed to justify his inclusion. With midfield competitors like Luca de la Torre and Sebastian Berhalter stepping up, Cardoso faces an uphill battle to reclaim his spot.

Sebastian Berhalter: The Surprise Package

Sebastian Berhalter has emerged as one of the tournament's most pleasant surprises. Initially seen as a depth option, the Vancouver Whitecaps midfielder has seized his opportunities with both hands. His standout performance against Saudi Arabia, where he won 57.1% of his duels and delivered a pinpoint set-piece for Chris Richards' winning goal, has significantly boosted his stock. Berhalter's tenacity and set-piece prowess have made him a viable option for the USMNT midfield.

Max Arfsten: A Square Peg in a Round Hole

Max Arfsten's Gold Cup campaign has been a mixed bag. While he provided two assists in the opening match, his defensive vulnerabilities have been exposed. Tasked with a more conservative role, the Columbus Crew left-back has struggled with possession and conservative passing. With John Tolkin impressing in his stead, Arfsten's future with the national team remains uncertain.

Looking Ahead

As the USMNT progresses to the knockout stages, the performances of these players will be crucial. For some, like Tillman and Berhalter, the Gold Cup has been a springboard to greater heights. For others, like Cardoso and Arfsten, it has been a reality check. The coming matches will determine who can rise to the occasion and secure their place in the USMNT's World Cup plans.