Deshaun Watson's Uncertain Future: Can the Cleveland Browns Recover from Their Costly Gamble?

The High-Stakes Gamble That Backfired

Cleveland Browns co-owner Jimmy Haslam made a startling admission at the NFL's annual meetings last week: "We took a big swing-and-miss with Deshaun." This marked the first public acknowledgment from the organization that their blockbuster 2022 trade for quarterback Deshaun Watson has failed spectacularly.

The Cost of Failure

The Browns gave up:

Three first-round draft picks (2022, 2023, 2024)
A 2022 third-round pick
2023 and 2024 fourth-round picks

In return, they received:

A quarterback whose 34.2 Total QBR ranks second-worst among qualified passers since joining Cleveland
Just 12 starts over three seasons
Mounting injuries including two Achilles tears

Injury Woes Compound Problems

Watson's Cleveland tenure has been marred by:

2022: 11-game suspension to start season
2023: Season-ending shoulder surgery after 6 games
2024: Ruptured Achilles after just 7 starts
2025: Second Achilles surgery, likely missing entire season

The Financial Quagmire

Watson's unprecedented fully guaranteed $230 million contract creates a nightmare scenario:

$173 million in remaining cap hits
$46 million annual salary through 2026
Potential record $135 million dead cap charge if cut after 2025

Potential Exit Strategies

Scenario	Cap Implications
Cut in 2025	$173M dead cap (single-season NFL record)
Post-June 1 2026 cut	$135M split over 2026-27
Play out contract	$81M cap hit in 2026

Drafting the Future

With the No. 2 overall pick, Cleveland may target:

Shedeur Sanders (Colorado)
Cam Ward (Miami)
J.J. McCarthy (Michigan)

General Manager Andrew Berry stated: "The position room will skew young as we again attempt to find our elusive franchise quarterback."

League Perspectives on Watson's Future

NFC Executive: "If released, I don't see anyone picking him up... would he even be motivated to play?"

NFL Agent: "The league is forgiving with quarterbacks that have exhibited high-level talent. A team could take a chance if he proves healthy."

The Long Road Ahead

The Browns face:

Immediate QB competition between Kenny Pickett and a potential rookie
Years of cap constraints from Watson's deal
Continued scrutiny over their evaluation process

As Jimmy Haslam summarized: "We need to see what Deshaun's health situation is before we make a decision." But with each passing month, that decision seems increasingly clear.